Best Kosher Steak Recipe (2 Ways: Pan-Seared or Grilled)

If you’ve been searching for the best kosher steak recipe, you’ve likely run into one major problem: almost every “perfect steak” guide calls for butter basting. But for those of us keeping kosher, butter simply isn’t an option when cooking meat. Don’t worry—this doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice that golden crust, juicy center, or rich flavor.

Whether you’re cooking indoors in a cast iron skillet or grilling outdoors over open flame, this recipe gives you two chef-approved, kosher-friendly ways to make the best steak of your life—no butter needed.

---

Key Elements to Making the Perfect Kosher Steak

To ensure your steak is absolutely perfect, follow these essentials:

1. Choose a Good Cut of Meat: Opt for a tender, well-marbled cut like ribeye or NY strip. These cuts have the right balance of fat and meat for flavor and tenderness.
2. Use a Cast Iron Skillet: For pan-searing, a cast iron skillet is crucial. It provides even heat distribution, high heat retention, and is perfect for basting with kosher fats.
3. Bring the Steak to Room Temperature: Before cooking, let your steak sit at room temperature for at least 30 minutes. This ensures even cooking and better searing.
4. Pat the Steak Dry: Moisture is the enemy of a good sear. Use paper towels to thoroughly pat your steak dry before seasoning.
5. Use Beef Tallow or Parve Margarine: Instead of butter, use beef tallow or kosher parve margarine for basting. Both provide rich flavor and a beautiful crust without compromising kosher laws.
6. High Heat: Whether pan-searing or grilling, make sure your cooking surface is preheated to high heat. This is essential for getting that golden-brown crust.
7. Use a Meat Thermometer: For the perfect doneness, use a professional meat thermometer like the ThermoMaven Digital Meat Thermometer for quick, accurate readings.

---

🧈 Why Butter Basting Is a No-Go in Kosher Cooking

Top chefs love basting steak with butter because it adds flavor and helps build a beautiful crust. The technique involves tilting the pan and spooning melted butter over the steak while it finishes cooking, infusing every bite with richness.

But here’s the thing: in kosher cooking, mixing meat with dairy is strictly prohibited. That means butter’s off the table when it comes to steak. Luckily, we’ve got two amazing substitutes that are 100% kosher and just as effective:

• Beef tallow: Pure rendered fat from kosher beef. Traditional, rich, and flavorful.
• Kosher parve margarine: A dairy-free butter alternative that mimics the texture and performance of real butter.

Use either to get the same basting results—crispy outside, juicy inside, and loaded with flavor.

---

Can I Use Olive Oil for Basting Kosher Steak?

This is a common question in kosher kitchens, and the short answer is: you can—but it’s not ideal.

Why Olive Oil Isn’t the Best for Basting:

• Low smoke point: Olive oil starts to break down and smoke around 375–400°F, which is too low for the high-heat sear you need to build a proper crust on steak.
• Thinner consistency: It doesn’t cling to the steak the way tallow or margarine does during basting, so the flavor and crust development are limited.
• Lacks depth: Olive oil doesn’t deliver the same rich, savory depth as beef tallow or parve margarine, both of which mimic the classic butter basting effect without compromising kashrut.

What’s Better for Basting Kosher Steak?

• Beef tallow (high smoke point + deep beefy flavor)
• Parve margarine (great butter alternative, kosher for meat)

When to Use Olive Oil:

You can still use olive oil to lightly coat the steak before grilling, or in marinades. Just avoid it for pan basting at high heat.

Bottom line: Stick to beef tallow or parve margarine when basting for best results—and full kosher compliance.

---

🍳 The Best Pan for Kosher Steak: Cast Iron Skillet

Forget non-stick pans. When it comes to getting that signature steakhouse sear, nothing beats cast iron.

Why Cast Iron Wins Every Time:

• Even heat distribution: Ensures a uniform crust.
• High heat retention: Maintains temperature when the steak hits the pan.
• Perfect for basting: Deep sides help hold in the fat, garlic, and herbs.

Non-stick pans simply don’t get hot enough and can even release toxic fumes at high temps. For steak, stick to the skillet—cast iron is king.

---

Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Skillet – Your Ideal Steak Partner

For cooking a perfectly seared kosher steak, a 12-inch Lodge Cast Iron Skillet is the go-to choice for many chefs. It offers unparalleled heat retention, which is key to achieving the perfect sear and even cooking.

Key Features:

• Pre-seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil for a non-stick surface that improves with use.
• Assist handle for better control when moving the skillet.
• Versatile: Use it on the stove, in the oven, or on the grill—this skillet works anywhere!
• Durability: Made from cast iron to last a lifetime with proper care.

Whether you’re searing a small steak or making side dishes, the 12-inch size is perfect for daily use.

👉 Buy it on Amazon: Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Skillet

---

Lodge 15-inch Cast Iron Skillet – Ideal for Large Cuts

If you’re planning on cooking multiple steaks at once or large cuts of meat, the Lodge 15-inch Cast Iron Skillet is your best option. Its large surface area ensures even cooking and prevents overcrowding, making it perfect for family-sized meals or entertaining guests.

Key Features:

• Pre-seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil to improve its non-stick cooking surface over time.
• Signature teardrop handle for easy control, even with a heavier skillet.
• Versatile: Whether you’re frying, baking, or grilling, this skillet performs exceptionally well.

This 15-inch skillet is perfect for larger cuts of meat or preparing multiple steaks at once.

👉 Buy it on Amazon: Lodge 15-inch Cast Iron Skillet

---

Protect Your Kitchen with the BergKoch Splatter Screen

When cooking steaks in your cast iron skillet, you’re bound to experience some grease splatter. The BergKoch Splatter Screen provides an easy way to keep your kitchen clean while ensuring that you avoid painful burns from hot oil.

Key Features:

• Protects hands from hot oil: Keeps oil from splattering on your skin, protecting you from painful burns.
• Keeps your kitchen clean: Prevents greasy splatter from making a mess on your stove, cabinets, and counters.
• Fits most cookware: Whether you use a 12-inch or 15-inch skillet, this splatter guard fits most frying pans and skillets.
• Heavy-duty stainless steel: Unlike silicone alternatives, this mesh splatter screen is durable, rust-free, and dishwasher safe.

The BergKoch Splatter Screen is essential when cooking steaks to reduce kitchen odors and protect you from hot oil while still allowing steam to escape.

👉 Buy it on Amazon: BergKoch 15-inch Splatter Screen

---

Professional Meat Thermometer for Perfect Results

To ensure your steak is cooked perfectly every time, a professional meat thermometer is essential. I recommend the ThermoMaven Professional Meat Thermometer for its accuracy and speed. This thermometer offers:

• Instant readings in 1 second
• NIST certified for precise temperature measurements
• Waterproof design for easy cleaning
• Auto-rotating screen for both right- and left-handed use

👉 Buy it on Amazon: ThermoMaven Professional Meat Thermometer

Affiliate Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase using these links, at no extra cost to you. Your support helps keep this site running and allows me to continue sharing great content. Thank you for your support!

---

🔪 Ingredients for the Best Kosher Steak

These ingredients work for both cooking methods—pan or grill.

Ingredients (Serves 2):

• 2 kosher steaks (ribeye or NY strip)
• Kosher salt and freshly cracked black pepper
• 2 tbsp avocado oil or canola oil (for searing)
• 2 tbsp beef tallow or parve margarine
• 3 garlic cloves, smashed
• 2 sprigs fresh rosemary or thyme

---

🔥 Method 1: Pan-Seared Kosher Steak (Cast Iron)

This method is perfect for cold days, weeknights, or when you want total control over the doneness. You’ll get a crusty exterior and perfectly juicy center.

Instructions:

1. Let the steak sit at room temperature for 30 minutes.
2. Pat dry thoroughly. Season all sides with kosher salt and pepper.
3. Heat cast iron skillet over high heat until smoking. Add oil.
4. Sear steak 2–3 minutes per side until a deep brown crust forms.
5. Reduce heat to medium-low. Add beef tallow (or margarine), garlic, and herbs.
6. Tilt the pan and baste continuously for 1–2 minutes.
7. Use a thermometer to check doneness:
   • Rare: 120–125°F
   • Medium-Rare: 130–135°F
   • Medium: 140–145°F
8. Transfer steak to a cutting board. Rest for 5–10 minutes before slicing.

Chef’s Tip: Slice against the grain for maximum tenderness. Top with flaky salt just before serving.

---

🌳 Method 2: Grilled Kosher Steak (Outdoor)

Nothing beats the smoky char of an outdoor grill. This method gives you a bold crust and adds an extra layer of flavor.

Instructions:

1. Preheat grill to high (set up 2 zones: hot and cool).
2. Lightly oil the grates. Season steak with kosher salt and pepper.
3. Sear over high heat for 2–3 minutes per side.
4. Move to cooler side of grill. Close lid and cook to desired doneness.
5. Optional: Heat beef tallow or margarine with garlic and herbs on the side. Baste steak before removing from the grill.
6. Let steak rest 5–10 minutes before slicing.

Grill Tip: Keep a foil pan with herb-infused fat next to the grill to warm while you cook. Baste hot off the fire.

---

🧂 Flavor Add-Ons (Optional but Amazing)

Want to kick it up a notch? Here are a few kosher-friendly flavor boosters:

• Coffee or cocoa rubs for deep umami
• Smoked paprika for a BBQ twist
• Crushed pink peppercorns for a floral bite
• Zhoug or chimichurri as a post-slice drizzle

---

🙋 FAQ: Your Kosher Steak Questions Answered

Can I use ghee instead of butter?
Nope! Ghee is clarified butter and still considered dairy in halacha. Stick to tallow or parve margarine.

Do I need a meat thermometer?
Absolutely. It’s the only way to guarantee perfect doneness. Try an instant-read digital one.

Can I use olive oil?
While olive oil works well for marinades or grilling, it’s not the best choice for pan-basting. For that, stick to beef tallow or parve margarine for rich flavor and high heat tolerance.

Is sous vide kosher?
Yes, if the equipment is kept kosher and only used for meat. It’s a great method to pre-cook before searing.

---

🐮 Final Thoughts: Making the Best Kosher Steak at Home

With just a few tweaks—like swapping butter for tallow and using a cast iron pan—you can make a steak that rivals any fine dining experience. Whether you’re indoors with a skillet or outside by the grill, the key is quality ingredients, proper technique, and kosher awareness.

This is more than just a steak—it’s the best kosher steak recipe you’ll ever cook.

Ready to fire it up?